Better Britain logo Better Britain Bureau

Independent, Manchester-rooted, evidence-led reporting and explainers.

See our other side-quests: What Brexit Costs Immigrants vs Billionaires

Labour Screw-ups Dashboard

A running, source-linked list of notable reversals, broken pledges, and messy climbdowns. Default view is newest first.

About this dashboard

This is mostly AI-generated, barely reviewed with linked sources. It will be updated occasionally.

We built it this way because manually digging through modern “bad news” and bullshit is slow, depressing, and usually not that informative — so we made a semi-automatic dashboard to catch Labour drama we might’ve missed.

Many of these are raised in the main Labour report, but there are probably a few that should be escalated for policy effects.

Spotted something missing or outright wrong?
Suggest an update to Labour-Screw-Ups.md (PRs/issues welcome). Suggest an edit.

Updated: Showing: 200 / 200
Actor: State: Category:
#39 Government

Government said it would appeal the High Court proscription ruling, leaving arrested/charged people in limbo.

#40 Government

The Palestine Action proscription ban triggered mass civil-disobedience arrests before being struck down as unlawful.

#91 Government Economy

CIPD survey: over a third of employers plan to cut hiring in response to Labour’s employment-rights reforms.

#190 Government Foreign policy pending/variable

Now reported to be considering bringing forward the 3% target anyway, implying the earlier plan wasn’t credible.

Notes / context
  • Defence spending 3% target timing: after refusing to put a date on it, they’re now reported to be considering bringing it forward. State: pending/variable (move not yet locked in). (Reuters)
#191 Government Economy

Employer survey: over a third plan to cut permanent hiring due to Labour’s employment-rights changes.

#200 Government Foreign policy

Defence spend promises landed without a published, comprehensive investment plan, worrying suppliers.

#147 Government Media Leadership Starmer

Labour-linked Labour Together got caught commissioning a dossier targeting journalists, prompting cross-party calls for an inquiry.

#148 Party Media Leadership Starmer

The same Labour Together affair included allegations of a paid “investigation” into reporters’ personal backgrounds (now under PR industry scrutiny).

#196 Government Leadership Starmer

Jonathan Powell reportedly rejected overtures to replace McSweeney as chief of staff.

#37 Government Justice Economy reversed-by-court

High Court ruled the proscription unlawful (Feb 13, 2026).

Notes / context
  • Court reversal: Palestine Action proscription: High Court ruled the ban unlawful; arrests/enforcement paused while government pursues appeal. State: reversed-by-court / legally unstable. (Garden Court Chambers)
#38 Government Justice Housing

Met Police paused arrests for “support” offences after the High Court ruling against the Palestine Action proscription, exposing enforcement chaos.

#185 Government Climate

Tony Blair Institute publicly accused Miliband’s approach of driving up costs and urged policy reversal.

#118 Government Leadership

Drove out the cabinet secretary amid the wider Mandelson crisis—public evidence of a system failing at basic due diligence.

#119 Government Leadership Starmer

Turned the cabinet secretary exit into a broader “clear-out” story, angering officials and raising payout/“ministerial direction” noise.

#149 Government Leadership

The Mandelson fallout was bad enough that Reuters reported successive top departures (aides + cabinet secretary) and a “reset” atmosphere.

#174 Government Economy Housing

External analysis said meeting the target would take “a miracle” given planning-application rates.

#121 Government

Had No 10 admit Doyle “did not give a full account” before the peerage—basic vetting blown.

#120 Government Leadership Starmer

Gave Matthew Doyle a peerage, then removed the whip after his support for a convicted child-sex-offender associate emerged.

#122 Government Media Leadership Starmer

Ended up with Labour chair-level figures saying Doyle should lose the peerage, because the appointment was indefensible.

#32 Government

Tim Allan quit as communications director after five months, deepening the No 10 churn.

#34 Government Leadership Starmer

Starmer faced resignation calls from within Labour during the Mandelson/Epstein appointment fallout.

#194 Government

Communications director resigned amid the same scandal’s blast radius.

#195 Government Leadership Starmer

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar publicly called for Starmer to resign.

#31 Government

Morgan McSweeney quit as chief of staff, taking responsibility for advising Mandelson’s appointment.

#193 Government

Chief of staff Morgan McSweeney quit over the Mandelson–Epstein fallout, signalling inner-circle breakdown.

#29 Government

Police searched addresses linked to Mandelson in a misconduct-in-public-office probe.

#28 Government Leadership Starmer

Starmer apologised to Epstein victims for appointing Mandelson.

#35 Government Leadership Starmer

Reuters framed the saga as a leadership-weakening “nightmare” of Starmer’s own making.

#27 Government Leadership Starmer acknowledged

Starmer said he regretted appointing Mandelson and accused him of repeated lies over Epstein ties.

Notes / context
  • Fixed-ish: Mandelson appointment fallout: Starmer went into public “regret” mode once the scandal detonated. State: acknowledged (not fixed). (Financial Times)
#30 Government Leadership Starmer U-turn mitigated

Mandelson resigned from the Lords amid the scandal, after vetting plainly failed.

Notes / context
  • Fixed-ish: Mandelson: resigned/quit roles under pressure, effectively undoing the appointment decision (damage done). State: mitigated (person removed), governance failure stands. (Reuters)
#33 Government Leadership Starmer

Government agreed to release Mandelson-appointment documents to the Intelligence and Security Committee.

#136 Government Foreign policy Leadership Starmer

China trip triggered criticism from UK and U.S. politicians (espionage + human rights accusations aired during the visit).

#137 Government Foreign policy Leadership Starmer

Reuters’ framing of the China “pivot”: it showcased the drawbacks of the strategy in real time.

#72 Government Welfare

Reconfirmed “no WASPI compensation” in the new decision, angering campaigners again.

#126 Government Leadership Justice Starmer

Doubled down on the jury-trial change in the face of internal rebellion headlines.

#138 Government Economy Leadership Foreign policy +2

Arrived encouraging firms to seize China opportunities while Western alliances were under strain—inviting predictable backlash.

#94 Government Economy Media U-turn mitigated

Announced a pubs support package (15% rates discount + freezes) after the backlash.

Notes / context
  • Pub business rates shock: after warnings about closures/jobs, they announced extra relief (discount + freezes). State: mitigated (cost pressure reduced), but it’s basically patching the earlier hit. (ICAEW)
#42 Government Justice

Tried to insert a security-service carve-out into the Hillsborough Law bill that campaigners said undermined the law’s purpose.

#44 Government Justice stalled/variable

Postponed the Commons vote/third reading on the Hillsborough Law bill until “agreement”, turning a promise into drift.

Notes / context
  • Hillsborough Law timetable: after the same row, they paused/delayed the bill to rework it. State: stalled/variable (nothing “fixed” until the reworked text lands). (Public Law Project)
#130 Government Leadership U-turn

Resolution Foundation publicly said the government had dropped/watered-down reforms and needed to be bolder after U-turns.

#150 Government Justice Protest rights Foreign policy

Picked fights (jury trials, SEND, China reset, freebies) that stacked into a single narrative: chaotic judgement + constant damage limitation, not calm competence.

#43 Government Justice Media U-turn mitigated

Pulled the amendment only after backlash from mayors/MPs/families.

Notes / context
  • Hillsborough Law carve-out for security services: they tried to write in an opt-out; after the backlash they pulled the amendment. State: mitigated (design fixed, bill still bruised). (ITVX)
#129 Government Justice Leadership Starmer

Internal Labour sources described the constant reversals as eroding MP loyalty (jury trials + SEND explicitly cited).

#45 Government Justice

Admitted the Hillsborough Law bill was stuck in wrangling over national-security exemptions and scope.

#54 Government

Shifted the digital ID plan to optional IDs alongside passports/visas, conceding civil-liberties criticism.

#55 Government Justice Digital rights U-turn mitigated

Kicked the “optional” scheme out to 2029 after staking political capital on compulsion.

Notes / context
  • Digital ID rollout posture: shifted to “right-to-work checks digital by 2029, but digital ID itself optional / other digital proofs accepted”. State: mitigated (less intrusive), credibility hit remains. (Pinsent Masons)
#66 Government Welfare U-turn

The welfare-reform row became part of the broader “series of U-turns” story line.

#99 Government Digital rights

Even after dropping mandatory digital ID, kept pushing mandatory digital right-to-work checks.

#128 Government Leadership Justice Elections +1

Floated SEND changes that sparked an organised campaign warning ministers not to strip children’s legal rights.

#93 Government Economy U-turn

Faced warnings a business-rates rise for pubs would close venues; signalled a climbdown.

#53 Government Digital rights U-turn rectified-ish

Dropped the “mandatory” requirement for workers in another U-turn (Jan 2026).

Notes / context
  • Mandatory digital ID “to work” requirement: the hard mandate was dropped/blurred so it wasn’t “digital ID or you can’t work”. State: rectified-ish (core coercion reduced). (Full Fact)
#84 Government Economy Media U-turn mitigated

Softened the farm/business inheritance-tax relief change by raising thresholds after months of protests.

Notes / context
  • Farm/business inheritance-tax relief threshold: raised the threshold to £2.5m after sustained backlash/protests. State: mitigated (most affected cases relieved), original policy judgement still the “wrong bit”. (GOV.UK)
#86 Government Economy Media

Ended up doing damage-control comms on the farm inheritance-tax change (“tractor tax”) rather than landing a stable settlement.

#172 Government Housing

Official target framed as 1.5m homes, while Reuters’ deep-dive showed forecasts implying a shortfall risk.

#173 Government Housing

Independent tracking suggested the pace would miss the pledge without a major acceleration.

#162 Government NHS

Emergency-appointment pay tweaks were dismissed by the BDA as “no new money”.

#183 Government

Overhauled grid connections to purge “zombie projects”, acknowledging years of backlog dysfunction.

#125 Government Justice

Proposed cutting jury trials for many cases via judge-only courts—scrapping a historic right to tackle the backlog.

#49 Government

Took until Dec 2025 to appoint a grooming-gangs inquiry chair/panel and publish draft terms.

#135 Government Media Leadership Economy +2

Called China a “national security threat” while pushing deeper business ties—trying to have it both ways in a high-stakes relationship.

#184 Government Climate

Great British Energy only set out its five-year plan in Dec 2025, leaning heavily on private capital to do the job.

#87 Government Economy U-turn mitigated

Watered down “day-one” unfair-dismissal protection to a 6-month qualifying period.

Notes / context
  • “Day-one” unfair dismissal: dropped the day-one pledge and settled on a 6-month qualifying period. State: mitigated (business fear addressed), credibility hit + worker-promise dilution. (Acas)
#88 Government Economy Media

Government press release explicitly set out the 24-months→6-months compromise after talks.

#89 Government Economy U-turn

Reuters reported the softening as business-pushback driven; unions split on the climbdown.

#90 Government Economy

ACAS guidance now reflects the 6-month rule, locking in the broken “day-one” pledge.

#127 Government Leadership Justice Starmer

Warned the plan to slash jury trials (expanding judge-only courts) could worsen unfairness/miscarriages for Black and minority ethnic defendants (a predictable own-goal).

#179 Government Climate Housing

Promised £150 bill cuts by scrapping ECO (insulation help for low-income homes), drawing fuel-poverty warnings.

#180 Government Climate

Shifted most Renewables Obligation costs from bills to general taxation instead of fixing underlying pricing.

#186 Government Economy Climate

Allowed some new oil/gas field development despite the “no new licences” pledge, muddying signals.

#198 Government

Reuters noted Labour collapsing to under ~20% poll support at one point, a self-inflicted legitimacy problem.

#79 Government Leadership Economy Starmer

Floated extending income-tax threshold freezes (stealth tax), stoking “manifesto breach” claims.

#160 Government NHS

Asked the competition regulator to probe private dentistry pricing because NHS access had imploded.

#177 Government Housing

Pushed “default yes” homes around stations and threatened ministerial override of council refusals.

#123 Government Leadership Starmer

Let allies brief that Starmer would face down leadership bids and name possible challengers, then publicly distanced himself.

#124 Government

Reuters’ readout of the leadership-plot rumours moment: authority shaken, rift deepened, and MPs complaining of “bunker mentality”.

#156 Government Leadership U-turn mitigated

Exposed a surge in prisoners released by mistake (“each week”), with ministers calling it unacceptable.

Notes / context
  • Fixed-ish: Prisoners released in error: announced an independent investigation + immediate stronger release checks. State: mitigated (process tightened), but it’s still a competence incident. (GOV.UK)
#159 Government Justice

Summoned prison chiefs to urgent meetings as wrongful releases became a rolling scandal.

#171 Government Economy

Briefed/trailed extending the income-tax threshold freeze (a big revenue-raiser via fiscal drag).

#134 Government Justice Foreign policy

Pressed ahead with high-level China visits despite an espionage-trial outcry.

#178 Government Justice Economy U-turn mitigated

Had to tweak planning overhaul to curb legal challenges and council blocking, i.e. fix the fix.

Notes / context
  • Planning overhaul “tweak”: amended their planning push to reduce blockers (incl. legal-challenge/throughput changes). State: mitigated (implementation more workable), not a clean U-turn so much as patching. (GOV.UK)
#52 Government Digital rights

Pitched compulsory digital ID for workers/right-to-work as anti-illegal-migration policy.

#98 Government Leadership Digital rights Media +1 U-turn

Sold digital ID as an anti-illegal-migration fix, then walked it back under backlash pressure.

#41 Government Justice

Launched the Hillsborough Law bill with big “duty of candour” rhetoric (Sept 2025).

#51 Government Leadership Immigration Digital rights +1

Announced mandatory digital ID cards for all adults as an immigration measure (Sept 2025).

#181 Government Climate

Reuters reported UK industrial power prices as a top barrier to net zero, with perverse subsidy incentives.

#116 Government Media Housing

Lost homelessness minister Rushanara Ali after reports she evicted tenants and re-let at +£700/month.

#117 Government Leadership Housing

Built a pattern of ministerial exits “under pressure” (Ali explicitly described as another embarrassing blow).

#19 Government

Settled claims linked to the leaked antisemitism dossier, reportedly costing ~£2m.

#36 Government

Parliament approved proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist organisation (July 2025).

#60 Government Welfare Leadership Starmer

Forced the welfare reform bill through amid visible damage to authority and party unity.

#59 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer U-turn mitigated

Offered concessions (limiting cuts to new claimants) to head off the rebellion.

Notes / context
  • Welfare cuts: scaled back the package after internal revolt pressure (notably narrowing who would be hit). State: mitigated (harm reduced), but it’s still the same fight resurfacing. (Financial Times)
#64 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer U-turn

The concessions turned into another high-profile U-turn narrative for the government.

#58 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer

Faced an open revolt threat from Labour MPs over disability/sickness benefit changes.

#62 Government Welfare Leadership Starmer

Let welfare reform become a rolling whip-count crisis on its own benches.

#65 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer

Took the welfare fight into a high-stakes Commons showdown with sustained internal opposition.

#188 Government Economy Foreign policy

Publicly signed up to 5% defence+security by 2035 without saying where the money comes from.

#192 Government Economy Foreign policy

After building expectations, decided the China relations audit wouldn’t be published separately “in the national interest”.

#48 Government

Asked the National Crime Agency to chase historic grooming-gang cases, underlining earlier inertia.

#170 Government Justice Education

Triggered (and then had to ride out) a wave of court challenges over the private-school VAT move.

#69 Government Welfare Economy U-turn rectified

Treasury confirmed the U-turn: restored payments to millions; £1.25bn cost.

Notes / context
  • Winter fuel payments (the actual reversal): restored payments for most pensioners, with recovery via tax above the £35k line. State: rectified (policy outcome largely reversed). (GOV.UK)
#81 Government U-turn

Justified the winter-fuel U-turn by claiming finances had improved, contradicting earlier posture.

#18 Opposition Foreign policy

Let Gaza policy become an internal equality flashpoint (LMN survey: disquiet + Islamophobia concerns).

#182 Government Climate

Industry warned government has “one moon shot” to sort energy costs and policy certainty, or it’s failure.

#70 Government Welfare Economy

Ministers insisted universal winter fuel is dead, keeping the political wound open.

#176 Government Media

Planning bill provoked a Labour MP revolt over protected habitats/wildlife.

#189 Government Leadership Foreign policy Starmer

Refused to put a date on hitting 3% of GDP for defence, leaving the “ambition” as vibes.

#47 Government Leadership Starmer U-turn rectified

U-turned on the grooming gangs inquiry and agreed to a national statutory inquiry (Jun 2025).

Notes / context
  • Grooming gangs inquiry stance: moved from resisting/limiting the idea to announcing a statutory national inquiry. State: rectified (politically), but late and reactive. (Institute for Government)
#154 Government Justice

Floated mandating chemical castration for sex offenders as part of “freeing space” reforms.

#155 Government Justice

Opened the door to earlier release / community-serving options that domestic-abuse groups warned could endanger survivors.

#67 Government Leadership Welfare Media +1

Cut/means-tested winter fuel payments, sparking backlash from Labour MPs and unions.

#68 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer U-turn mitigated

Starmer signalled a winter-fuel U-turn by widening eligibility after months of refusing to budge.

Notes / context
  • Winter fuel payments (the “we’re changing this” phase): signalled/confirmed a climbdown after the cut became politically toxic. State: mitigated (direction changed), but messy. (The Guardian)
#132 Government Foreign policy

Briefed the China audit as “early June”, then ended up being delivered to parliament late June (missed expectation).

#133 Government Leadership Foreign policy Starmer

Reuters reported Starmer declined to condemn the jailing of Hong Kong pro-democracy activists at the G20—looked like moral silence for access.

#73 Government

Left a vacuum long enough for fake “WASPI compensation” scams to proliferate.

#157 Government Leadership

Confirmed 91 prisoners freed in error since April 2025, with some still at large.

#57 Government Welfare

Announced >£5bn welfare cuts by 2029/30, provoking internal unrest.

#63 Government Welfare

Sold welfare cuts as “fairness” while MPs argued it failed disabled people.

#175 Government Housing

Moved to slash/limit statutory consultees to speed housing, effectively admitting the system was jammed.

#187 Government Leadership Economy Foreign policy +1

Boosted defence spending while cutting the international aid budget to pay for it.

#115 Government Standards

Let the WhatsApp scandal escalate to a parliamentary standards investigation into Gwynne.

#113 Party Standards

Suspended MP Oliver Ryan over the same WhatsApp group, widening the scandal.

#112 Government Standards Leadership Starmer

Sacked and suspended junior health minister Andrew Gwynne over offensive WhatsApp messages.

#46 Government

Announced only “new local inquiries” on grooming gangs after pressure, not a statutory probe.

#109 Government Standards

Lost Siddiq anyway when she resigned over the reputational damage/conflict optics.

#110 Government Standards

Had an ethics adviser say “no breach” over Tulip Siddiq but still flag serious reputational risk—exactly the sort of appointment that should’ve been avoided.

#111 Government Standards

Made the “anti-corruption” brief itself look farcical by giving it to someone engulfed by corruption-linked reporting.

#108 Government Leadership Starmer

Publicly backed Tulip Siddiq while she was under pressure over a Bangladesh corruption probe.

#139 Government NHS

Talked up restoring the 18-week standard, while data showed every acute trust in England missing it.

#199 Government Climate

Reuters pointed to CCC analysis saying the UK was off-track for net zero, highlighting the scale of the gap Labour inherited and hadn’t closed.

#131 Government Foreign policy

Quietly pared back the promised China audit into something less critical to smooth a “reset”.

#83 Government Protest rights Economy U-turn

Insisted there would be “no U-turn” on the farm tax during early protests.

#197 Government Economy

Reuters’ Breakingviews framed the non-dom overhaul as a risky “lab rat” experiment for the rich-tax perk reform.

#26 Government Leadership Starmer

Appointed Peter Mandelson as US ambassador (Dec 2024), inviting predictable blowback.

#105 Government Elections Leadership

Put Louise Haigh in cabinet, then had her resign after her fraud conviction resurfaced.

#106 Government Standards

Took a reputational hit from Louise Haigh’s phone-fraud story right after promising “integrity”.

#107 Government Leadership

Forced an urgent transport secretary replacement within hours of Haigh’s resignation.

#82 Government Protest rights Economy Media

Introduced inheritance-tax changes hitting family farms, triggering the “tractor tax” backlash.

#85 Government Protest rights Economy

Farming protests repeatedly shut down central London as a visible political own-goal.

#78 Government Economy

Companies flagged >£1bn extra labour costs tied to post-budget NIC/wage changes.

#144 Government Standards Leadership Starmer U-turn mitigated

Tightened ministerial conduct/transparency rules after the donations row—because the original regime wasn’t enough for his own team.

Notes / context
  • Fixed-ish: Transparency rules after freebies: tightened ministerial disclosure/standards rules post-scandal. State: mitigated (controls strengthened). (Reuters)
#74 Government

Reeves raised employers’ National Insurance to 15% from April as a flagship revenue-raiser.

#75 Government Economy

Froze/extended key thresholds in ways critics framed as stealth taxation (fiscal drag politics).

#163 Government Economy

Put up capital gains tax rates in the first budget, landing a clear investor-facing tax hike.

#168 Government Economy

Still tightened non-dom rules in the budget, explicitly betting it wouldn’t trigger a millionaire flight.

#165 Government Immigration Economy

Delivered the biggest tax-raising budget in decades, blowing a hole in “no return to high tax” vibes.

#145 Government

Donor Waheed Alli was found to have breached parliamentary rules in the wake of the freebies row.

#76 Government Economy

Tried to dodge the manifesto “no NI rise” promise via semantics about “working people”.

#77 Government Economy

Full Fact documented how the NI pledge was being interpreted and contested post-budget.

#164 Government Media Leadership Economy +1

Let “CGT to 39%” speculation run hot enough that Starmer had to publicly swat it down.

#142 Government Media

Had to repay thousands in gifts (incl. high-profile hospitality) after public criticism of “freebies”.

#169 Government Economy Education

VAT on private school fees was framed as a political gamble that split opinion hard.

#21 Opposition

Opened the door to dropping Lords reform/abolition promises (another flagship wobble).

#166 Government Economy

Non-dom crackdown was reported internally as potentially raising nothing (or worse), risking a funding gap.

#167 Government Economy U-turn mitigated

Watered down non-dom plans after “listening to concerns” (including exodus talk).

Notes / context
  • Non-dom crackdown: softened the planned reforms after “listening to concerns” (explicitly framed as watering down). State: mitigated (edges softened), fiscal/credibility questions persist. (Sky News)
#146 Government Media Leadership Starmer

Walked into conference under pressure over winter-fuel cuts and donation-funded clothing/hospitality stories—self-inflicted political drag.

#143 Government Leadership Starmer U-turn mitigated

Announced he’d stop taking clothing donations only after the story detonated.

Notes / context
  • Fixed-ish: “Freebies” / clothes donations: stopped taking clothing donations after the row. State: mitigated (behaviour changed), doesn’t undo the original optics. (ITVX)
#141 Government Standards Leadership Starmer

Broke parliamentary rules by not declaring donor-funded high-end clothing for Victoria Starmer (reported as a breach).

#151 Government Justice

Announced expanded early release from Sept 2024 to avert a “breakdown of law and order” from overcrowding.

#61 Government Leadership Welfare Starmer

Suspended multiple Labour MPs for rebelling over the two-child benefit cap.

#153 Government Leadership Starmer

Had Starmer publicly concede the prisons situation was shocking/reckless enough to demand emergency moves.

#103 Opposition Elections

Withdrew support from a Labour candidate caught up in the election betting investigation.

#104 Opposition Elections

Lost a Labour candidate mid-campaign after sexual-harassment allegations became a “distraction”.

#101 Opposition Media U-turn rectified

Let the Diane Abbott candidature drift into public confusion, then reversed course after backlash.

Notes / context
  • Diane Abbott candidature: after public confusion/backlash, Labour said she could stand. State: rectified (decision reversed), reputational damage remains. (Reuters)
#102 Opposition Equalities

Turned Abbott handling into a wider row about racism and internal discipline.

#14 Opposition Leadership Elections Starmer

Dropped Faiza Shaheen as a Labour candidate in a high-profile selection row.

#3 Opposition Leadership NHS Education +1

Abandoned the 2020 leadership pledge to abolish university tuition fees.

#4 Opposition Leadership Welfare NHS +1

Explicitly ruled out scrapping the two-child benefit cap pre-election on affordability grounds.

#17 Opposition Foreign policy

Triggered a Commons meltdown over the Gaza ceasefire motion and amendments (Feb 2024).

#8 Opposition Leadership Equalities Starmer

Dropped self-ID as Labour’s policy for Gender Recognition Act reform.

#7 Opposition Leadership Starmer

Accepted the line that water nationalisation “doesn’t stack up” under fiscal rules.

#12 Opposition Leadership Elections Starmer

Formally barred Jeremy Corbyn from standing again as a Labour candidate.

#6 Opposition Leadership Climate Education +1

Softened/ditched long-held nationalisation commitments (rail/water/energy) in the “fiscal rules” era.

#23 Opposition Leadership Starmer

Banned frontbenchers from joining picket lines, picking a fight with parts of the labour movement.

#1 Opposition Climate

Scrapped the £28bn-a-year green investment plan after championing it since 2021.

#16 Opposition

Proscribed four internal groups in 2021, exposing members to automatic expulsion.

#20 Opposition

Apologised and paid “substantial damages” in the Panorama whistleblower defamation settlement.

#100 Government Leadership Housing Elections +1

Flagged as off-track on the headline “1.5m homes” ambition, exposing delivery gaps.

#15 Opposition Leadership

Sacked Rebecca Long-Bailey from the shadow cabinet over sharing antisemitic material.